When someone dies, their jewellery has to be valued for probate — the legal process of distributing the estate. It is a specific kind of valuation, done under specific rules, and it is not the same number as the one on an insurance policy. Getting it wrong means either overpaying inheritance tax or, worse, an HMRC enquiry later. This is the plain-English version.
Probate value is not replacement value
An insurance valuation is the cost of replacing the ring new, at retail. A probate valuation is the open-market value — roughly what the item would fetch at auction or a second-hand jeweller, which is usually 20–40% of the insurance figure. HMRC expects this lower number, because probate tax is calculated on what the estate is worth, not on what it would cost to replace the items.
What HMRC expects
- A written valuation from a qualified valuer (often a gemmologist or NAG member) on headed paper.
- Itemised list: each ring, watch or necklace described individually, not lumped together.
- For items over £1,500 individually, a specific valuation rather than a lump estimate.
- Photographs, especially for signed or vintage pieces, to support the valuation.
| Item | Insurance replacement value | Typical probate value |
|---|---|---|
| 1ct diamond solitaire, 18ct | £5,000 | £1,500–£2,200 |
| Vintage signet ring | £800 | £300–£450 |
| Gold chain, 10g 18ct | £600 | £350–£450 (scrap-ish) |
| Designer watch | £3,000 | £1,200–£2,000 |
What it costs and where to get it
A probate valuation usually costs £80–£150 for a small collection, more for a large estate. High-street jewellers, auction house valuations departments and independent gemmologists all offer it. Choose someone who will give you a probate-specific report — not an insurance valuation, which will overstate the figure and could overpay tax. Keep the report with the probate papers; HMRC can ask to see it up to four years after the estate is settled.
When jewellery actually affects the tax bill
In the UK, inheritance tax at 40% applies above the nil-rate band — currently £325,000 per person, rising to £500,000 where a main home passes to direct descendants. For many estates, the jewellery does not push the total over that threshold, and the valuation is done for completeness rather than because tax is due. For larger estates, though, an accurate probate valuation matters: overstate the jewellery and the estate overpays tax; understate it and HMRC can open an enquiry later. The valuer's job is to land on the open-market number, not a round figure.
Timing and who attends the valuation
The valuation is usually done after death, as part of sorting the estate. If the deceased had a known jewellery collection, it is sensible to have it valued promptly rather than waiting, because sentimental family arguments over specific pieces are easier to settle when there is a written number on the table. Keep the pieces together until they are valued; a ring box emptied into a shared jewellery box loses its itemised provenance.
Jewellery that has been gifted during life
Small gifts made in the seven years before death can fall out of the estate, but large ones — a family ring given three years before — still count. If you are administering an estate and unsure whether a piece was gifted or inherited, keep the jewellery with the estate until the valuer and a solicitor have looked at it. Getting it wrong means either a delayed grant of probate or a later correction from HMRC.
Jewellery versus gold scrap
Bullion — plain gold chains, coins, bars — is valued by weight and purity, not by jewellery craft. A 10g 18ct chain is essentially its gold weight minus a small making allowance. A ring with a diamond, by contrast, is valued for the stone and the craft on top of the metal. This distinction matters in a probate valuation: a box of old gold rings will be valued close to scrap, while a single solitaire will be valued as a piece of jewellery. Do not lump them together on the schedule; itemise, and let the valuer price each correctly.
Keep the receipt, keep the valuation
If you are administering an estate and you find old jeweller's receipts, insurance schedules or probate valuations from decades ago, keep them. They are the starting point for the new valuation, and they help the valuer distinguish a costume piece from a real one. Jewellery without paperwork is still valued, but the valuer has to do more work, and the figure can land lower on the day.
A competent probate valuation is a small cost that prevents a much larger mistake. Itemise the collection, use a qualified valuer, and keep the report with the estate papers. Done right, it takes a morning and causes no surprises later.
For the living-equivalent — valuing a ring you are about to insure — our ring insurance cost guide covers the other kind of valuation.
For third-party reference, the Wikipedia article on moissanite details moissanite’s discovery, optical properties and use in jewellery.
Related Reading
- Sweat and Jewelry: Which Metals Survive Everyday Wear
- Cleaning Jewelry: Which Cloths Actually Scratch Your Pieces
- Cleaning Moissanite: Why Toothpaste Is the Wrong Cleaner
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I verify a factory before placing a bulk order?
Request a production video, business license, export records and a paid sample run. A factory that accepts a 50-piece test order is usually a real manufacturer.
What payment terms do you offer?
30% T/T deposit with the balance against the bill of lading. This protects both sides on first orders and can move to net terms after a track record.
What is your normal reject rate?
3–5% under 10x loupe inspection for cast and set pieces. Defective units are replaced free in the next shipment.
Where is the factory located?
Wuzhou, Guangxi, China—the core lab-grown and moissanite manufacturing cluster. Shipments go via Guangzhou or Shenzhen ports.